Saturday, January 05, 2019

Re: Advice on Security Cameras

Hi,

zoneminder is, as Stuart said, overcomplicated, plus unmantained and unable
to catch the more modern streams from IP cams.
The best free alternative is SHINOBI https://shinobi.video which is based
on java and ported on linux, mac and wi(n)dows, I do not know it it would
be feasible an OpenBSD port (theorically yes
https://gitlab.com/Shinobi-Systems/Shinobi/tree/master/INSTALL contains the
stuff).

On amd64 platform it works great!
I am soon going to install it on an ODROID-HC1, although I read around that
on arm (unsupported) platform motion detection is crippled.


On Fri, Jan 4, 2019 at 7:07 PM Stuart Henderson <stu@spacehopper.org> wrote:

> On 2019-01-01, kayasaman <kayasaman@gmail.com> wrote:
> > Hi. For this type of setup Zoneminder is great. I have no experience
> running it on OpenBSD though.
>
> There is an unfinished zoneminder port in openbsd-wip. I must say the
> architecture looked rather overcomplicated to me ..
>
> multimedia/motion is simpler and supports uvideo and some network cameras
> but maybe too simple.
>
> > As for cameras have you looked at HikVision? They are very reasonable
> pricewise when compared with say Axis.
>
> HikVision and Dahua have good reasonably-priced cameras. I don't know
> about other markets but in the UK most of these seem to stop their
> distributors showing prices publically. (There was a point hikvision
> tried to restrict distribution to only "official" installers too, but
> this stupidity seems to have subsided a bit since). Haven't tried them
> via OpenBSD though. (Most of the decent installations I have seen use
> Milestone's software on Windows which they are fairly happy with).
>
> I wouldn't say anything good for security for any of this type of device.
> It is all crap. IMHO put cams on at least a dedicated vlan if not fully
> separate network infrastructure and don't let them have access to or from
> the internet. If you need to connect to them from outside the network,
> bounce your connections off another machine.
>
> Another reply mentioned onvif. This is no magic "it will do useful
> things" bullet and it is pretty bare bones. If you have software in
> mind then look for cameras particularly listed as being supported.
>
>
>

No comments:

Post a Comment