Saturday, October 31, 2020

Re: assembler error on trying to port OpenBLAS

On 10/31/2020 12:57 PM, Aisha Tammy wrote:
> On 10/29/20 8:25 PM, Aisha Tammy wrote:
>> Hi,
>> I'm trying to port OpenBLAS to the tree and am currently getting
>> some weird assembler errors (port makefile is attached at end
>> math/openblas)
>>
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c: Assembler messages:
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:37: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vbroadcastss (%rcx),%ymm0'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:38: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups (%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm8'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:39: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 32(%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm9'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:40: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 64(%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm10'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:41: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 96(%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm11'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:42: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups (%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm4'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:43: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 32(%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm5'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:44: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 64(%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm6'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:45: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 96(%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm7'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:51: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm4,%ymm0,%ymm4'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:52: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm8,%ymm4,%ymm12'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:53: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm5,%ymm0,%ymm5'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:54: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm9,%ymm5,%ymm13'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:55: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm6,%ymm0,%ymm6'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:56: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm10,%ymm6,%ymm14'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:57: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm7,%ymm0,%ymm7'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:58: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm11,%ymm7,%ymm15'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:59: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups (%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm8'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:60: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 32(%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm9'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:61: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 64(%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm10'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:62: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 96(%rdx,%rax,4),%ymm11'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:63: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups (%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm4'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:64: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 32(%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm5'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:65: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 64(%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm6'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:66: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups 96(%rsi,%rax,4),%ymm7'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:67: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm12,-128(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:68: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm13,-96(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:69: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm14,-64(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:70: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm15,-32(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:75: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm4,%ymm0,%ymm4'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:76: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm5,%ymm0,%ymm5'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:77: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm6,%ymm0,%ymm6'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:78: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmulps %ymm7,%ymm0,%ymm7'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:79: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm8,%ymm4,%ymm12'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:80: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm9,%ymm5,%ymm13'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:81: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm10,%ymm6,%ymm14'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:82: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vaddps %ymm11,%ymm7,%ymm15'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:83: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm12,-128(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:84: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm13,-96(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:85: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm14,-64(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:86: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vmovups %ymm15,-32(%rdx,%rax,4)'
>> ../kernel/x86_64/saxpy_microk_sandy-2.c:87: Error: no such
>> instruction: `vzeroupper '
>>
>>
>> Presumably this is happening due to the assembler being used is
>> the one from base as we don't build the ports egcc with gas for
>> anything except aarch64 and arm.
>> I'm kind of stumped here as it seems like using gfortran sets the
>> compiler to egcc (compiling the above file with cc works).
>> Is it possible to mix gfortran with base-clang C compiler?
>> Another (possible) solution would be to build egcc all archs with
>> the new gas assembler, but that sounds a lot more dangerous and I
>> don't know enough to know if that is possible/or even a good idea/
>> or if it will even work :-/
>>
>> Any pointers would be cool to have.
>> (I've cc'ed pascal@ as they are the maintainer for gcc port and
>> can be better suited to answer the second point of gas)
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Aisha
>>
>>
>> # $OpenBSD $
>>
>> COMMENT    =    optimized BLAS/LAPACK library based on GotoBLAS
>> PKGNAME =    ${DISTNAME:L}
>> CATEGORIES =    math
>>
>> GH_ACCOUNT =    xianyi
>> GH_PROJECT =    OpenBLAS
>> GH_TAGNAME =    v0.3.12
>>
>> SHARED_LIBS =    openblas 0.0 \
>>          blas 7.2 \
>>          cblas 7.2 \
>>          lapack 7.2 \
>>          lapacke 7.2
>>
>> MAINTAINER =    Aisha Tammy <openbsd@aisha.cc>
>>
>> # BSD
>> PERMIT_PACKAGE =    Yes
>>
>> WANT_LIB +=    c m pthread
>>
>> MODULES =    fortran
>> MODFORTRAN_COMPILER =    gfortran
>>
>> USE_GMAKE =    Yes
>>
>> MAKE_ENV =    CFLAGS="${CFLAGS}" FFLAGS="${CFLAGS}" \
>>          LIBopenblas_VERSION="${LIBopenblas_VERSION}" \
>>          LIBblas_VERSION="${LIBblas_VERSION}" \
>>          LIBcblas_VERSION="${LIBcblas_VERSION}" \
>>          LIBlapack_VERSION="${LIBlapack_VERSION}" \
>>          LIBlapacke_VERSION="${LIBlapacke_VERSION}" \
>>          USE_THREAD=1 USE_OPENMP=0 \
>>          NUM_PARALLEL=8 \
>>          NUM_THREADS=64 \
>>          MAKE_NB_JOBS=-1 \
>>          DYNAMIC_ARCH=1 \
>>          TARGET=GENERIC \
>>          NO_AFFINITY=1 \
>>          NO_STATIC=0 \
>>          BUILD_RELAPACK=1
>>
>> .include <bsd.port.mk>
>>
>
> Thanks for the people who commented.
> I've managed to fix the error by forcing the
> COMPILER_LINKS = cc /usr/bin/cc gcc /usr/bin/gcc

But that's not an option for something that is to be commited to the tree.

No comments:

Post a Comment